Wednesday, February 4, 2009

I Think I'd Rather Have the Cash

Apparently, it’s becoming trendy to pay your kids allowance in “screen time” instead of cold, hard cash. If you are having issues regulating computer / TV time I guess this is one way to handle it. Maybe somebody should make a coin activated Bob and then you can pay the kids in cash and get it back when they feed dollar bills into Bob to get online :)

Seriously though, what do you think of this idea? I can’t imagine any reasonable parent regulating access to books, or board games in this way. Why is it different just because it’s electronic and interactive? My 10 year old daughter spends a lot of time playing Horse Isle. In fact, of more than 30,000 people playing the game, she currently has the 2nd most valuable horse. She has to understand the rules of the game, apply them in way to maximize the value of her horses, negotiate trades and sales with other players, synthesize the new additions to the game and decide how to best use them, etc. Reading comprehension, applying the rules, finding the loopholes that can be exploited for advantage, and negotiating all sound like fairly good skills to have in both video games and real life. Both kids like to browse Wikipedia. Why would I limit that but give them unlimited access to a set of hardbound encyclopedias? My son owns books on Roman Legion infantry tactics because he thought they would help him get higher scores in Rome: Total War. (I don’t know if it actually helped). He knows far more about ancient Rome than I do, yet he has never had a “class” that covered it. Again, why would I limit that?

The line between education and entertainment has become very blurry. There is a lot going on in games and online in general that is directly applicable to education. It’s not as simple as schoolwork happens in the books and fun happens in the games. It’s all mixed up now, and as parents I think we need a more nuanced view of the value of gaming or online time. Certainly a lot of time can be wasted online. But a lot of good happens there too.

Humorous aside - check out the picture in the article. The boy is wailing on Guitar Hero about 3 feet from where his sister is trying to do homework. I hope that was just a posed picture for the paper and not the normal set up in that house!

2 comments:

Mark Sicignano said...

Is education and entertainment really mixed together? The horse might be the 2nd most valuable horse in that game, but it's not a real horse. Do you it has better prepared your child to work with real horses?

Interactive does not necessarily mean education. It may mean, "engaging", but kids can get sucked into it for hours on end, just the way that cartoons on TV can.

And a tens of thousands of clicks on the keys during a session of "play" may not really be all that complex.

Read Dr. Jane Healy's book "Failure to Connect". It will give you a different outlook than the one that you're expressing above.

Mad Dog Murf said...

I am a single parent and when my children were growing up, I would buy every learning software I could buy. The problem was that was the last time it was ever opened! It became shelfware. I suffered with parental guilt! So, I developed a software solution. It does not compete with web surfing or instant messaging. It complements it! Here it is: www.MasteryPro.com Mastery Pro Executive Summary You’re wasting your money buying educational software...if your kids never use it; Even the best designed educational software does not compete for a child's attention compared to video games, TV and online chats with friends. And can you monitor them? MasteryPro is, simply put, a patented software program that is designed to temporarily interrupt a computer or gaming machine and force the user to participate in some form of mastery learning. It will restart precisely where it stopped upon the user completing a short task that is prescribed by the pass coded administrator. Students/users are rewarded for good behavior by earning additional time on the computer or game. It provides appropriate feedback to students, explains the correct answer, and contains a management system to keep track of student progress and blindly emails the results to the teacher. The computer monitors correctness, timeliness and the parameters of all actions. MasteryPro improves focus, sharpens memory, reduces stress, and increases the capacity to master new information. MasteryPro was developed primarily to auto educate students of all ages as well as adults that want to force themselves to learn a skill or prepare for a government license through Mastery Learning. i.e. 7th grade math, pilots license, SAT, Civil Service, Real Estate, Vocabulary, Drivers license, Foreign Languages, LSAT, Product knowledge, etc.; building blocks for more meaningful learning. The system allows the Parent/administrator to design, create, modify, and distribute the learning modules to other trainees. The trainer may define a series of questions: either true or false, multiple choices, numeric, matching, or essay. MasteryPro is distributed free via the internet with a limited amount of learning modules (capitals, trivia, earth quake readiness, child fire prevention etc.) by distributors like download.com. Once the end user downloads the free program, they will be invited to buy, via the Internet, additional learning modules for relevant grade levels as well as any other areas of learning. The basic module will allow the user to prepare custom tests. MasteryPro will be upgraded free via the Internet, which can be easily customized to address the educational needs of practically any discipline. We will send the test maker module out to teachers free and encourage them to get their students on MasteryPro. MasteryPro will become the portal to all educational software. MasteryPro will aid in the parents need to train their children in a busy and dangerous world and reduce parental guilt. CEO Mad Dog Software, LLC. 10 Media Center Drive Lake Havasu City, AZ 86403 928.704.7272 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uuFKUXZZtVo